Surefire X300 Ultra vs Streamlight TLR-1 HL (Expert Comparison)

When it comes to weapon-mounted lights, the Surefire X300 Ultra and Streamlight TLR-1 HL are two of the most popular choices.

If you have already built a firearm, installed the lower parts kit, and added a slide, you are now ready for a weapons light.

But which one comes out on top when real users put it to the test? One experienced shooter recently shared their hands-on comparison of these two tactical illumination powerhouses. Let’s dive into their key insights and takeaways.

Which is better? Surefire X300 vs Streamlight TLR-1 (Compared)

Surefire vs Streamlight Form Factor Differences

The size and shape of a weapon-mounted light can make a big difference in how it performs and fits your pistol. Let’s take a closer look at the key physical differences between the Surefire X300 Ultra and the Streamlight TLR-1 HL.

• The X300 Ultra is noticeably longer, extending further past the muzzle compared to the more compact TLR-1 HL.
• Surefire’s finish was found to be more durable, easily withstanding powder blast residue. The TLR-1’s anodized finish showed some hazing after firing.
• The TLR-1’s shiny chrome accents stood out in a distracting way compared to the X300’s sleeker, lower-profile aesthetics.
• Streamlight’s mounting system was more versatile, fitting a wide array of guns and rails. The X300 was simpler, clipping right onto Glock frames.

Surefire vs Streamlight Brightness & Beam Characteristics

Lumens and candela are important factors to consider when choosing a tactical pistol light. Here’s how the beam patterns and brightness of the X300 Ultra and TLR-1 HL compare in the real world.

• On paper, the X300 Ultra is rated at 500 lumens vs 630 lumens for the TLR-1 HL. But output numbers don’t tell the whole story.
• The X300 Ultra’s LED is focused by a deep reflector, creating a bright, tightly focused hotspot that excels at longer ranges. Its spill is wide and even.
• The TLR-1 HL’s shallower reflector and more forward LED placement creates more of a floodlight effect, sacrificing some throw for a brighter area right around the hotspot.
• Neutral white tint of the X300 Ultra was preferable to the TLR-1 HL’s cooler (more blue) color temperature.

Surefire vs Streamlight Real-World Performance & Concluding

Thoughts Understanding how these two popular tactical lights perform under real-world conditions is key to making an informed decision. Our reviewer shared some valuable insights and recommendations based on their hands-on experience.

• While 500+ lumens may seem like overkill indoors, with proper training and technique, that much power can be an asset, allowing users to identify targets without muzzling them.
• The X300 Ultra’s tighter beam is optimal for outdoor longer-range use. The TLR-1 HL’s balanced throw/spill is great for urban environments and closer ranges.
• Ultimately, the TLR-1 HL delivers outstanding performance at a roughly 40% lower cost compared to the X300 Ultra. Those on a budget won’t be disappointed.
• The X300 Ultra’s sleeker form factor, more durable finish, and premium build may be worth the extra investment for those running Glocks or wanting max throw distance.

Conclusion

Choosing between the Surefire X300U and the Streamlight TLR-1 HL comes down to your specific needs and budget.

Both weapon lights offer ample illumination for target identification and shooting in low-light conditions.

By carefully considering the factors outlined in this real-world comparison, you’ll be well-equipped to decide which one is the best tactical light for you.